Journey of a Strong-Willed Child

I have not one, but two strong-willed children. I readily admit that it's often exhausting, and if I didn't realize their souls are in jeopardy if I don't help them focus their natural tendencies (after all, we must all learn to obey God), I might be tempted to throw up my hands and let them have their way. They. Wear. Me. Out. I, myself, was not a strong-willed child (I was stubborn, but obedient), and while I've read a number of books about raising strong-willed children, none of them has given me insight in my children nearly as much as Kenda, Aaron, and John Smiley's book Journey of a Strong-Willed Child.

First, let's be clear. Despite what some say, not all children are strong-willed. A strong-willed child doesn't just want her way, she wants to be in control of every aspect of her life. As the authors wisely state: "The strong-willed child will choose the stated punishment in order to be in control, especially if the child considers the punishment moderate...A strong-willed child may choose to miss a party, not get dessert, or be sent to his room, because those things are really no big deal. A guilt-ridden parent (this is a false guilt induced by the strong-willed child) is not likely to choose to fight that particular battle again. The child is now running the show. The strong-willed child has chosen a small sacrifice for a big payoff." Wow. My preschooler to a T. So how did the Smiley's get so smart? One day some friends with a strong-willed child visited, seeking advice. Unexpectedly, one of their children (then in college) dropped by. The family friends were shocked when they'd begin telling a story about their strong-willed child and Aaron was easily able to finish the tale. You see, Aaron had unique insight into the strong-willed child. It hadn't been so long ago that he was one. It's Aaron's insights that make this book truly unique and helpful. Two other gems I found particularly helpful: * Strong-willed children usually have a black and white sense of right and wrong, justice and injustice. Often, their strong-willed tendencies are magnified if they think someone has been wronged. In fact, if they were adults, and we shared their sense of justice, we'd be cheering them on as heros! * All children appreciate honesty from adults, answers like "I don't know, but let's find out." But strong-willed children are especially appreciative. In fact, strong-willed children can spot an immature adult from a mile away - and will try to assert themselves over him or her. The book is divided into chapters covering the various stages of childhood: birth to pre-K, Kindergarten to 6th grade, Jr. High, High School, and College. In each chapter, mom Kendra discusses pertinent points for parents, such as consistencies in disciple, helping your child make his strong-willed nature an asset, and (as a parent) keeping encouraged. Next, former strong-willed child Aaron adds his own, unique insights. Finally, dad John offers a little extra parental wisdom. Although there is some how-to information included (like how to cope with teachers who don't understand strong-willed kids, how to prevent sibling rivalry when you have a strong-willed child, and so on), I find this book is especially useful as a guide to how your strong-willed child thinks. The focus in on the long-term picture: Helping your child to Christ - and to a productive, content life. This book is encouraging, insightful, eye-opening, and liberating. I highly recommend it. Bookmark and Share

4 comments

  1. What I liked about this book was the insights from the kid, now a man. It was very helpful to understand what my son might be thinking while testing me so frequently. :)

    Have you read "Raising Your Spirited Child" yet? That one changed our lives. It's not written from a Christian perspective, but it is packed with valuable information.

    I wouldn't say I have two strong-willed kids, but I definitely have two SPIRITED kids. They're just spirited in opposite ways. One is aggressive; the other is emotional. One is persistent and perceptive; the other is impatient and controlling. Parenting is by far the most difficult job I've ever had. Perhaps the most difficult I can imagine!

    ReplyDelete
  2. "Raising Your Spirited Child" is in my to-read pile :) I'm looking forward to it!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have been reading books on strong willed children since my first born was born. I read the Spirited Child and I was just not convinced. I don't think that parents bending backwards to make their children feel more comfortable, or in control is what life is all about. Now that my child is almost 7 y.o. it has become easier since she understands a lot more. I can talk to her and explain the reasons behind the commands, the authority of parents, schedule and other things. Yes, I would love for her to just obey instead of "making a fuss" about everything, but I think they need to understand how life is. Who in the real world is going to make her life comfortable for her so that she won't go bananas? I understand that people are different, but people need to learn to adapt themselves to their environment, not the other way around. (think mission field, waiting in line at an airport, using holes on the ground as toilets, walking in dirty clothes etc etc) I really find it annoying to have to label every child and every behavior. How did parents do 100 years ago? Anyway, I have a 4th baby on the way and things are getting better and better, because Father God has reminded me of His Grace that was given to me on the cross when Jesus died for me. I just want to bask in His Grace and It will take care of everything else. After all, it's because of His Grace I am here. :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Tereza, I haven't read "Spirited Child" yet, so I can't really comment on it. I know what you mean about labels; they can be convenient, but also limiting. However, labels have always been used for kids. They didn't used to be so politically correct, though :) 100 years ago, a child was "lazy," or a "dreamer," or "willful," or even a "dunce." I definitely don't believe in bending over backwards to make my child feel better - although there are days when kids (and adults!) need a little extra grace.

    ReplyDelete